Technorati tages = metacrap ?

TrackBacks (1) Comments (1)

While the world falls in love with folksonomies and tagging, Dare Obansanjo mutters "Bah humbug, seen it all before".

All the problems with META tags are still valid today most important being the fact that people lie especially spammers and that even well intentioned people tend to categorize things incorrectly or according to their prejudices.

Not sure whether I agree with him or not, but it's Monday morning, I've been ill for most of the week, and I'm feeling contrary.

1 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Technorati tages = metacrap ?.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.digitalquery.com/cgi-bin/mtcs/mt-tb.cgi/49

» Is there a problem with tagging from Knowledge Jolt with Jack

scale|free and many others have suggested "Technorati tags = metacrap" by drawing a connection to the previous META tag on web pages. I think tags work differently and will provide value, even if they get "spammed." Read More

» from Knowledge Jolt with Jack

1 Comments

I have to say that Technorati tags will largely result in junk... however, since they use MT's categories, they might get some tags to work correctly, such as a tag titled 'Apple' or 'Music' will likely be mostly used appropriately. However, will this lead to the fabled 'semantic web'?? I have to say no way.

I love tags, but see them being beneficial primarily for personal use right now. del.icio.us is a great example of tags put to good use, however they work best when one person makes all the tags. Most of my tags are setup for my personal organization (like 'summer-job') but some tags ('cooking', 'photography') have a broader use and are useful on a global level.

Leave a comment

Recent Entries

Your intranet app...
Having spent a fair amount of time consulting on intranets and internal applications, as well as being on the receiving…
14 (now 18) alternatives and additions to basecamp.
I was looking around for some alternatives to Basecamp, and was pretty surprised to see that there are a ton of…
IABC Commonwealth Chapter
Despite the waves of jetlag that ocassionally threaten to leave me faceplanted on a table, I'm having fun here in…